Journal of Transport and Land Use

The built environment and the determination of fault in urban pedestrian crashes: Toward a systems-oriented crash investigation

Jonathan Stiles

The Ohio State University

https://orcid.org/0000-0001-7613-1814

Harvey Miller

The Ohio State University

https://orcid.org/0000-0001-5480-3421

DOI: https://doi.org/10.5198/jtlu.2024.2335

Keywords: Pedestrian, Traffic Crashes, Safe Systems, Vision Zero, Transportation Equity

---

Abstract

This study identifies built environmental factors that influence the determination of fault in urban pedestrian crashes in the United States, with implications for both safety and equity. Using data from Columbus, Ohio, we apply regression modeling, spatial analysis, and case studies, and find pedestrians are more likely to be found at fault on fast, high-volume arterial roads with bus stops. We also observe that better provision of crossings leads to more marked intersection crashes, which are less likely to be blamed on pedestrians. In addition, large differences in both the provision of crossings and fault exist between neighborhoods. We interpret findings through the lenses of the systems-oriented safety approaches Safe Systems and Vision Zero. The conclusion argues that the designation of individual responsibility for crashes preempts collective responsibility, preventing wider adoption of design interventions as well as systemic changes to the processes that determine the built environment of US roadways.

---

References

Al-Mahameed, F. J., Qin, X., Schneider, R. J., & Shaon, M. R. R. (2019). Analyzing pedestrian and bicyclist crashes at the corridor level: Structural equation modeling approach. Transportation Research Record, 2673(7), 308–318.

Arrington, G. B., R. Cervero, National Research Council, Transportation Research Board, Abay, K. A. (2015). Investigating the nature and impact of reporting bias in road crash data. Transportation Research Part A: Policy and Practice, 71, 31–45.

Belin, M. Å., Tillgren, P., & Vedung, E. (2012). Vision Zero—A road safety policy innovation. International Journal of Injury Control and Safety Promotion, 19(2), 171–179.

Bernhoft, I. M., & Carstensen, G. (2008). Preferences and behavior of pedestrians and cyclists by age and gender. Transportation Research Part F: Traffic Psychology and Behavior, 11(2), 83–95.

City of Columbus. (2018). Columbus communities. Retrieved from https://opendata.columbus.gov/datasets/columbus-communities/

Clifton, K. J., Burnier, C. V., & Akar, G. (2009). Severity of injury resulting from pedestrian–vehicle crashes: What can we learn from examining the built environment? Transportation Research Part D: Transport and Environment, 14(6), 425–436.

Corben, B. (2020). Integrating safe system with movement and place for vulnerable road users (No. AP-R611-20). Sydney, Australia: Austroads.

Cottrill, C. D., & Thakuriah, P. V. (2010). Evaluating pedestrian crashes in areas with high low-income or minority populations. Accident Analysis & Prevention, 42(6), 1718–1728.

Doecke, S. D., Kloeden, C. N., Dutschke, J. K., & Baldock, M. R. (2018). Safe speed limits for a safe system: The relationship between speed limit and fatal crash rate for different crash types. Traffic Injury Prevention, 19(4), 404–408.

Dumbaugh, E., & Rae, R. (2009). Safe urban form: Revisiting the relationship between community design and traffic safety. Journal of the American Planning Association, 75(3), 309–329.

Dumbaugh, E., Saha, D., & Merlin, L. (2020). Toward safe systems: Traffic safety, cognition, and the built environment. Journal of Planning Education and Research, 0739456X20931915.

Dumbaugh, E., & Zhang, Y. (2013). The relationship between community design and crashes involving older drivers and pedestrians. Journal of Planning Education and Research, 33(1), 83–95.

Ewing, R., & Dumbaugh, E. (2009). The built environment and traffic safety: A review of empirical evidence. Journal of Planning Literature, 23(4), 347–367.

Fahlquist, J. N. (2006). Responsibility ascriptions and vision zero. Accident Analysis & Prevention, 38(6), 1113–1118.

Faria, J. J., Krause, S., & Krause, J. (2010). Collective behavior in road crossing pedestrians: The role of social information. Behavioral Ecology, 21(6), 1236–1242.

Furbee, J., & Overking, D. (2018). Police legal advisor’s update—Summer in the city. Columbus, OHL Columbus City Attorney.

Gayah, V. V., Guler, S. I., Liu, H., Blackburn, L., & Hamilton, I. (2022). Quantification of systemic risk factors for pedestrian safety on North Carolina. Raleigh, NC: NCDOT.

Goddard, T., Ralph, K., Thigpen, C. G., & Iacobucci, E. (2019). Does news coverage of traffic crashes affect perceived blame and preferred solutions? Evidence from an experiment. Transportation Research Interdisciplinary Perspectives, 3, 100073.

Gooch, J., Hamilton, I., Polin, B., Tanzen, R., & Cohen, T. (2022). Systemic safety analysis of midblock pedestrian crashes in Massachusetts. Transportation Research Record, 2676(11), 722–730.

Hauer, E. (2016). An exemplum and its road safety morals. Accident Analysis & Prevention, 94, 168–179.

Havard, C., & Willis, A. (2012). Effects of installing a marked crosswalk on road crossing behavior and perceptions of the environment. Transportation Research Part F: Traffic Psychology and Behavior, 15(3), 249–260.

Johansson, R. (2009). Vision Zero–Implementing a policy for traffic safety. Safety Science, 47(6), 826–831.

Kim, K., Brunner, I. M., & Yamashita, E. (2008). Modeling fault among accident—Involved pedestrians and motorists in Hawaii. Accident Analysis & Prevention, 40(6), 2043–2049.

Kim, K., Li, L., Richardson, J., & Nitz, L. (1998). Drivers at fault: Influences of age, sex, and vehicle type. Journal of Safety Research, 29(3), 171–179.

Kumfer, W., LaJeunesse, S., Sandt, L., & Thomas, L. (2019). Speed, kinetic energy, and the Safe Systems approach to safer roadways. ITE Journal. 89(4).

Lee, D. J. (2014). The unbearable weight of irresponsibility and the lightness of tumbleweeds. In S. Zavestoski & J. Agyeman (Eds.), Incomplete streets: Processes, practices, and possibilities (pp. 77–93). London: Routledge.

Leveson, N. (2004). A new accident model for engineering safer systems. Safety science, 42(4), 237–270.

Loukaitou-Sideris, A., Liggett, R., & Sung, H. G. (2007). Death on the crosswalk: A study of pedestrian-automobile collisions in Los Angeles. Journal of Planning Education and Research, 26(3), 338–351.

McFadden, D. (1974). The measurement of urban travel demand. Journal of Public Economics, 3(4), 303–328.

Merlin, L. A., Guerra, E., & Dumbaugh, E. (2020). Crash risk, crash exposure, and the built environment: A conceptual review. Accident Analysis & Prevention, 134, 105244.

Medury, A., Grembek, O., Loukaitou-Sideris, A., & Shafizadeh, K. (2019). Investigating the underreporting of pedestrian and bicycle crashes in and around university campuses—A crowdsourcing approach. Accident Analysis & Prevention, 130, 99–107.

Motor vehicles-aeronautics-watercraft, Section 4511.46, Right-of-way pedestrian within crosswalk. (2018). Retrieved from https://codes.ohio.gov/ohio-revised-code/section-4511.46#:~:text=(A)%20When%20traffic%20control%20signals,the%20Revised%20Code%2C%20to%20a

Naumann, R. B., Heiny, S., Evenson, K. R., LaJeunesse, S., Cooper, J. F., Doggett, S., & Marshall, S. W. (2019). Organizational networks in road safety: Case studies of US Vision Zero cities. Traffic Injury Prevention, 20(4), 378–385.

Naumann, R. B., Sandt, L., Kumfer, W., LaJeunesse, S., Heiny, S., & Lich, K. H. (2020). Systems thinking in the context of road safety: Can systems tools help us realize a true “Safe Systems” approach? Current Epidemiology Reports, 7, 343–351.

Noland, R. B., Klein, N. J., & Tulach, N. K. (2013). Do lower income areas have more pedestrian casualties? Accident Analysis & Prevention, 59, 337–345.

Norton, P. D. (2011). Fighting traffic: The dawn of the motor age in the American city. Cambridge, MA; MIT Press.

Ohio Department of Public Safety. (n.d.). Ohio crash report procedure manual. Columbus, OH: Ohio Department of Public Safety.

Ohio Traffic Safety Office. (n.d.). OH-1 Resources for law enforcement. Columbus, OH: Ohio Department of Public Safety, Ohio Traffic Safety Office.

Ralph, K., Iacobucci, E., Thigpen, C. G., & Goddard, T. (2019). Editorial patterns in bicyclist and pedestrian crash reporting. Transportation Research Record, 2673(2), 663–671.

Rosen, E., Stigson, H., & Sander, U. (2011). Literature review of pedestrian fatality risk as a function of car impact speed. Accident Analysis & Prevention, 43(1), 25–33.

Sanders, R. L., Judelman, B., & Schooley, S. (2019). Pedestrian safety relative to traffic speed management. A synthesis of highway practice. Washington, DC: Transportation Research Board.

Sciortino, S., Vassar, M., Radetsky, M., & Knudson, M. M. (2005). San Francisco pedestrian injury surveillance: Mapping, under-reporting, and injury severity in police and hospital records. Accident Analysis & Prevention, 37(6), 1102–1113.

Singh, S. (2015). Critical reasons for crashes investigated in the national motor vehicle crash causation survey (No. DOT HS 812 115). Washington, DC: National Highway Traffic Safety Administration.

Schneider, R. J., Proulx, F. R., Sanders, R. L., & Moayyed, H. (2021). United States fatal pedestrian crash hot spot locations and characteristics. Journal of Transport and Land Use, 14(1), 1–23.

Spainhour, L. K., & Wootton, I. A. (2007). Modeling fault in fatal pedestrian crashes by using various data sources. Transportation Research Record, 2002(1), 64–71.

Tao, W., Mehndiratta, S., & Deakin, E. (2010). Compulsory convenience? How large arterials and land use affect midblock crossing in Fushun, China. Journal of Transport and Land Use, 3(3), 61–82.

Tefft, B. C. (2013). Impact speed and a pedestrian's risk of severe injury or death. Accident Analysis & Prevention, 50, 871–878.

Thomas, L., Sandt, L., Zegeer, C., Kumfer, W., Lang, K., Lan, B., … & Schneider, R.J. (2018). Systemic pedestrian safety analysis (No. Project 17-73). Washington, DC: Transportation Research Board.

Tingvall, C., & Haworth, N. (1999). Vision Zero—An ethical approach to safety and mobility. Paper presented to the 6th ITE International Conference Road Safety & Traffic Enforcement: Beyond 2000, Melbourne, September 6–7.

Ukkusuri, S., Miranda-Moreno, L. F., Ramadurai, G., & Isa-Tavarez, J. (2012). The role of built environment on pedestrian crash frequency. Safety Science, 50(4), 1141–1151.

Ulfarsson, G. F., Kim, S., & Booth, K. M. (2010). Analyzing fault in pedestrian–motor vehicle crashes in North Carolina. Accident Analysis & Prevention, 42(6), 1805–1813.

USDOT. (2022). U.S. Transportation Secretary Pete Buttigieg announces comprehensive national roadway safety strategy. Retrieved from https://www.transportation.gov/briefing-room/us-transportation-secretary-pete-buttigieg-announces-comprehensive-national-roadway

Weinstein Agrawal, A., Schlossberg, M., & Irvin, K. (2008). How far, by which route and why? A spatial analysis of pedestrian preference. Journal of Urban Design, 13(1), 81–98.

Vision Zero Columbus. (2021a). Vision Zero Columbus crash data. Retrieved from https://columbus.maps.arcgis.com/apps/MapSeries/index.html?appid=0ff6f8f1fa134b848959ba4fc3c35bbb

Vision Zero Columbus. (2021b). Action plan 1.0. Retrieved from https://www.columbus.gov/vzactionplan

Yannis, G., Golias, J., & Papadimitriou, E. (2007). Modeling crossing behavior and accident risk of pedestrians. Journal of Transportation Engineering, 133(11), 634–644.

Yu, C. Y., & Xu, M. (2018). Local variations in the impacts of built environments on traffic safety. Journal of Planning Education and Research, 38(3), 314–328.